Judith A. Waltz

Partner

Overview

Judith A. Waltz is a partner and business lawyer with Foley & Lardner LLP. Her practice focuses on government investigations, false claims act, corporate integrity agreements (CIAs), bankruptcy, and Medicare and Medicaid counseling. Judith works with clients in various areas of the health care industry. She is the co-chair of the firm’s Health Care Industry Team and former co-chair of the Life Sciences Industry Team. Judith is also a member of the Government Enforcement Defense & Investigations and Bankruptcy & Business Reorganizations Practices.

Fraud and Abuse, FCA and Health Care Fraud Investigations

Judith regularly advises clients who are the focus of government investigations and other enforcement actions, and has negotiated false claims act settlements with the U.S. Department of Justice as well as corporate integrity agreements (CIAs) with the Office of Inspector General. She then has worked closely with those clients to implement their CIAs, including ongoing advice in connection with IRO audits and reviews. At the state level, she has been involved with various Medi-Cal audits, payment suspensions, and investigations, including a matter involving allegations of inflated drug pricing by a major pharmaceutical company. In 2004, she represented Gambro Healthcare, Inc., an entity with more than 500 sites, in CIA negotiations with the OIG, and subsequently was featured in the September 2005 cover story of Counsel to Counsel magazine for this work.

Medicare and Medicaid

Judith also provides ongoing compliance counseling and Medicare and Medicaid payment advice to clients, which include hospices, large physician practices, county health systems, hospitals, durable medical equipment suppliers, clinical laboratories, dialysis companies, skilled nursing facilities, ambulance companies, pharmacies, managed care providers, and a variety of other health care entities. In 2013, she served as special Medicare counsel in the bankruptcy of San Diego Hospice, a large not-for-profit entity. Judith has advised clients (including physician practices, hospice, and hospitals) undergoing ZPIC, RAC audits, other Medicare or Medicaid audits, and pre-pay reviews. She is experienced in Medicare and Medi-Cal provider enrollment appeals, and Medicare billing number deactivations and other enforcement actions.

Prior to joining the firm in 1998, Judith served as assistant regional counsel for the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services in San Francisco, primarily handling Medicare issues including survey and certification and various types of reimbursement disputes. In that position, she appeared frequently before the Ninth Circuit and other federal courts in matters primarily involving payment disputes (including PRRB appeals), bankruptcy issues, and Medicare Secondary Payer disputes. She held collateral appointments as a special assistant United States attorney for the Eastern and Northern districts of California.

Health Care Litigation

As assistant regional counsel for the Department of Health and Human Services for 12 years, Judith represented the secretary in the Ninth Circuit and other federal courts in matters primarily relating to disputes regarding Medicare payments to providers and suppliers. These cases included several court appeals of Provider Reimbursement Review Board decisions involving Medicare cost reports. In the bankruptcy and district courts, she briefed and argued the government’s case in In re TLC Hospitals, Inc., later decided by the 9th Circuit in 224 F.3d 1008 (9th Cir. 2000), upholding Medicare’s ability to recoup pre-petition overpayments from post-petition overpayments. She also represented the government in various bankruptcy court actions involving the assumption of the Medicare provider agreement as an executory contract, a debtor’s challenge to a hospital decertification action taken post-petition, and post-petition payment suspension actions. As an additional part of her government representation, she served as primary counsel in various proceedings involving the Medicare Secondary Payer (MSP) provisions. Since joining Foley in 1998, Judith has represented providers and suppliers who are under investigation relating to their participation in the Medicare and Medi-Cal programs, including negotiating settlements and corporate integrity agreements relating to issues including hospice admissions, clinical laboratory claims, partial hospitalization services, inpatient short stays, costs claimed on cost reports, oxygen (DME) billing, and assorted allegations of upcoding. She also recently served as lead counsel in an administrative appeal of the imposition of a Medi-Cal civil money penalty. She has appeared in several administrative appeals before the federal HHS Departmental Appeals Board, including decertification actions taken under the Clinical Laboratory Improvement Act (CLIA), civil monetary penalties, and adverse enrollment actions, and in overpayment appeals heard by the Office of Medicare Hearings and Appeals. In addition, she has represented providers and suppliers in the OIG’s Self-Disclosure Protocol, and in CMS’s Self-Disclosure Referral Protocol.

Telemedicine Experience

Judith has advised on compliance and reimbursement issues relating to business structures for providing telemedicine, requirements of the Medicare Conditions of Participation for hospitals which are participating in telemedicine services, applicable Medicare and Medicaid enrollment issues for telemedicine providers, and operational issues such as supervision of non-physician practitioners across sites. She has also worked extensively with the Clinical Laboratory Improvement Act (CLIA), payer and compliance requirements regarding laboratory verbal and electronic orders and results.

Thought Leadership

Judith is a frequent speaker and writer on health care and life science compliance issues, including overpayments, payment suspensions, corporate integrity agreements, off-label marketing, drug and device pricing, and potential issues of personal liability for owners of entities who are the focus of government scrutiny.

Recognition

Judith has been consistently ranked as one of the top health care attorneys in California by Chambers USA (2009 - 2019) where she is described as “the gold standard for issues with CMS” (2015) and “a leader in fraud and abuse” and “a masterful negotiator” (2014). 

In 2019, Chambers USA commented:

Judith Waltz is ‘tremendously experienced’ in a broad range of healthcare matters, including Medicaid and Medicare issues, and government investigations. Clients note that ‘she conveys advice in a way that is friendly, calming and reassuring.’

In addition, Judith was previously recognized by The Legal 500 for her work in life sciences in 2017, and for her work in the area of health care – service providers in 2015.

Education

Judith received her B.A., J.D. and M.P.A. degrees from Indiana University, where she was an associate instructor in the School of Business and a teaching assistant in the School of Public and Environmental Affairs (SPEA). As an undergraduate, she served as vice president of the Indiana University Student Association, the student government organization for the Bloomington campus. Judith currently serves on the Board of Visitors for Indiana University’s Maurer School of Law.

Admissions and Professional Affiliations

Judith is admitted to practice before the Ninth Circuit and all Federal District Courts for California. She was admitted to the California Bar in 1982.

Judith serves as a vice chair of the Regulation, Accreditation, and Payment Practice Group of the American Health Lawyers Association (AHLA). Judith is a past chair of the Women’s Network Steering Committee at Foley. She is a member of the American Health Lawyers Association (serving as a vice chair for the Regulatory, Accreditation, and Payment Practice Group), the Health Law Committee of the Business Law Section of the State Bar of California (serving as vice chair of education), the American Bar Association’s Health Law Section, the California Society for Healthcare Attorneys, the Healthcare Businesswomens' Association, and the Health Care Compliance Association.

Selected Publications and Presentations

Key Publications

  • “Administrative Enforcement Tools,” Health Law Handbook, 2017 Edition (2017) (co-author)
  • “New Medicare Beneficiary ID Card to Enhance Security,” Health Law Resource Center (May 2017) (quoted)
  • “OIG Finalizes New Exclusion Powers; Enrollment Lies, Omissions Are Risks,” Report on Medicare Compliance, Volume 26, Number 2 (January 16, 2017) (quoted)
  • “In Exclusion Guidance, Compliance Plans Are a Given; OIG Favors Self-Disclosure,” Report on Medicare Compliance, Volume 25, Number 25 (April 25, 2016) (quoted)
  • “OIG 2015 Work Plan, Part 1: Do fewer projects mean a sharper focus?” HCCA Compliance Today (January 2015) (contributing author)
  • “Nursing Home's Ch. 11 Threatens Agency Police Powers,” Law360 (November 5, 2014) (quoted)
  • “ACA Payment Reporting Threshold Fuels Pharma Headaches,” Law360 (October 2, 2014) (quoted)
  • “The Business of Personalized Medicine,” Big3Bio (September 16, 2014) (highlighted)
  • “CMS SOW Cites First Areas for MA RAC Audits, but Leaves Questions on Impact,” Health Business Daily (August 18, 2014) (quoted)
  • “FDA Lab Test Oversight Will Touch Off Industry Tug-Of-War,” Law360 (July 31, 2014) (quoted)
  • “Office of Medicare Hearings and Appeals: ‘Growing Pains’ as Appeals Workload Increases to Record Levels,” The RAP Sheet, a publication of the American Health Lawyers Association Regulation, Accreditation, and Payment Practice Group (February 2013)
  • “California’s Medi-Cal Program Implements Affordable Care Act Fraud, Waste, and Abuse Provisions,” Foley Legal News Health Care (November 27, 2012) (co-authored) 
  • “GAO Report Assesses CMS’ Fraud Prevention System,” American Health Lawyers Association Practice Group Alert (November 19, 2012)
  • "Florida District Court Adopts Magistrate Judge’s Recommendation Reversing and Remanding ALJ’s/MAC’s Medicare Overpayment Determination," American Health Lawyers Association Practice Group Alert (August 2012) 
  • "CMS Issues FY 2013 Update for IPF PPS," American Health Lawyers Association Practice Group Alert (August 2012)
  • "CMS to Begin Recovery Audit Prepayment Review on August 27," American Health Lawyers Association Practice Group Alert (August 2012) (co-authored)
  • "Proposed Overpayment Regulations Issued for 60-day Refund Rule," Compliance Today (May 2012) (co-authored with Lawrence Vernaglia and Nathaniel Lacktman)
  • "CMS Issues Proposed Overpayment Refund Regulations for the 60-Day Rule," Legal News: Health Care (February 2012) (co-authored) 
  • "Top Ten Health Law Stories of 2011," Association of Corporate Counsel Web site (November 2011) (co-authored) 
  • "CMS Issues Final Rule Requiring States to Develop Medicaid Recovery Audit Contractor Programs," Legal News: Health Care (September 2011) (co-authored) 
  • "HHS Puts Stamp on Personalized Medicine," Genetic Engineering & Biotechnology (July 2011) (co-authored) 
  • "The HEAT Is On, Chicago: Practical Tips To Prepare," Health Law360 (May 2011) (co-authored) 
  • "Government Takes Another Step in Holding Corporate Executives Accountable in the Absence of Personal Wrongdoing," Legal News: Litigation (May 2011) (co-authored) 
  • "Sen. Grassley Introduces the Strengthening Program Integrity and Accountability in Health Care Act of 2011," Legal News: Health Care (March 2011) 
  • "Whistleblowers Take On Off-Label Marketing," Genetic Engineering & Biotechnology News (December 2010) (co-authored) 
  • "Executive Summary on CMS Proposed Rule on PPACA Enrollment Requirements," American Health Lawyers Association (October 2010) (co-authored) 
  • "U.S. Focuses Enforcement on Manufacturers," Medical Device and Diagnostic Industry (August 2010) 
  • "CMS Releases Final Rule for End-Stage Renal Disease Prospective Payment System (Effective January 2011)," American Health Lawyers Association (August 2010) 
  • "The Genomics and Personalized Medicine Act of 2010," Health Law360 (August 2010) (co-authored) 
  • "Reading Tea Leaves: An Update on Personalized Medicine: Innovation, Threats, and Opportunities," Bloomberg's Intellectual Property Law Report (July 2010) (co-authored) 
  • "Personalized Medicine: Innovation, Threats and Opportunities," Bloomberg's Intellectual Property Law Report (July 2010) (co-authored) 
  • "Walking the Line: When Providers "Go Wrong" Under Corporate Integrity Agreements," Compliance Today (June 2009) (co-authored) 
  • "CMS Makes Medicare Part D Data Available For the FDA Sentinel Initiative, External Research, and Other Outside Uses," The Health Lawyer, Volume 21, Number 3 (February 2009) (co-authored) 
  • "Bad Advice from Health Care Consultants May Lead to False Claims Act Liability for Both Consultants and Clients," ABA’s The Health Lawyer, Volume 16, Issue 3 (March 2004) (co-authored) 
  • "Am I My Company's Alter Ego? Theories of Alternative Liability for Debts to the Medicare Program," Foley & Lardner LLP (March 2003) (co-authored) 
  • "CMS Report Analyzes Factors Affecting the Marketing of Prescription Drugs," Drug Benefit Trends (March 2003) 
  • "Payment Suspensions and Withholds," AHLA publication entitled The RAP Sheet, Volume 5, Issue 2 (Summer 2002) (co-authored) 
  • "Injunctive Relief in Health Care Insolvencies," California Bankruptcy Journal, 24, No. 3 (1998) (co-authored)

Key Recent Presentations

  • “The Clock is Ticking: Complying with the 60 Day Refund Rule,” presenter, HFMA Northern California Webinar (May 2017)
  • “An In-House Counsel’s Guide to U.S. Administrative Enforcement Efforts After the Affordable Care Act,” panelist, Association of Corporate Counsel Webcast (June 2015)
  • “OIG Hospital Compliance Audits: Keeping Your Boat Afloat in Choppy Waters,” panelist, Health Care Compliance Association Regional Conference (June 2015)
  • “Federal Sunshine Act: Year Two,” panelist, Association of Corporate Counsel – Health Law Committee Webcast (May 2015)
  • “Medicare and Medicaid: Emerging Administrative Enforcement Tools,” panelist, AHLA Institute on Medicare and Medicaid Payment Issues (March 2015)
  • "Medicare’s Emerging Administrative Enforcement Tools," AHLA Institute on Medicare and Medicaid Payment Issues (March 2014) 
  • "CIA Focus Group," moderator, ACI’s 14th National Pharmaceutical Compliance & Enforcement Forum (March 2014)
  • "Medicare Part B Drug Pricing," panelist, American Conference Institute's Rx Drug and Pricing Boot Camp (November 2013)
  • "Medicare's Emerging Enforcement Tools: Revocations, Payment Suspensions and the CMS Fraud Prevention System," panelist, 2013 American Health Lawyers Association Fraud and Compliance Forum (September 2013)
  • "Who Will Pay?" panelist, CALBIO 2013 (June 2013)
  • "Assessing the Financial Impact of Corporate Integrity Agreements," 4th Annual Life Science Financial Forum (June 2013)
  • "Health Reform Compliance," 2013 CSHA Annual Meeting & Spring Seminar (April 2013)
  • "2012: The RAP Practice Group's Year in Review" and "CMS and the Amazing Technicolor Dream Contractors," panelist, American Health Lawyers Association Institute on Medicare and Medicaid Payment Issues (March 2013)
  • "Case Study: Staying Ahead of the Curve: Cost-Effective and Compliant Reporting Strategies Learned from CIA Reporting," panelist, American Conference Institute’s 4th Annual Forum on Physician Payment Disclosure & Aggregate Spend (October 2012)
  • "Enrollment/Payment Suspension as Enforcement Tools," panelist, American Health Lawyers Association Fraud and Compliance Forum (September 2012)
  • "Regulatory and Legal Risks: A Comprehensive Overview," panelist, ExL Pharma 11th MSL Best Practices Summit (September 2012)
  • "Avoiding Anti-Kickback Challenges Related to Pricing and Contracting," panelist, American Conference Institute’s 9th National Drug Pricing Boot Camp (May 2012)
  • "Negotiating False Claims Act Settlements and Corporate Integrity Agreements," panelist, Health Care Compliance Association’s 16th Annual Compliance Institute (May 2012) 
  • "The RAP Practice Group's Year in Review," panelist, American Health Lawyers Association (AHLA) Institute on Medicare and Medicaid Payment Issues (March 2012) 
  • "False Claims Act Enforcement on the Rise," panelist, Stafford Webinar (February 2012) 
  • "Key Involvement of Medical Communications Within CIAs," Q1 Productions Conference (January 2012) 
  • "Fundamentals of Medicare/Medicaid," panelist, American Bar Association Health Law Section Webinar (November 2011) 
  • "Case Study: Examining the Accelerated Reporting System Enacted Under a Corporate Integrity Agreement," panelist, American Conference Institute’s 3rd Annual Forum on Physician Payments Disclosure & Aggregate Spend (October 2011) 
  • "Enrollment/Payment Suspensions," panelist, AHLA/HCCA Fraud & Compliance Forum (September 2011) 
  • "Government Options for Collecting Medicare Overpayments," panelist, AHLA Annual Meeting (June 2011) 
  • "Understanding How Pricing Issues Tie Into Government Compliance and Enforcement Efforts," ACI's Rx Drug Pricing Boot Camp (June 2011) 
  • "Voluntary Disclosure and Overpayment and False Claims Act Liability," panelist, Health Care Compliance Association's 15th Annual Compliance Institute (April 2011) 
  • "The RAP Practice Group's Year in Review" and "Medicare Overpayment Demands and Collection," panelist, AHLA’s Medicare and Medicaid Institute (March 2011 and March 2012) 
  • "False Claims Act Compliance After the PPACA: Minimizing Liability Exposure From Healthcare Reform's Expanded Fraud and Abuse Provisions," panelist, Stafford Webinar (March 2011) 
  • "Regulation and Dissemination of Off-Label Information," FDA Boot Camp (August 2010) 
  • "Regulation, Accreditation, and Payment Voluntary Refunds of Overpayments Now Mandatory: New Deadlines, Definitions, and Difficulties for Providers, Suppliers, and Plans Resulting from Healthcare Reform Legislation," panelist, AHLA Annual Meeting & In-House Counsel Program's Practice Group Luncheon (June 2010) 
  • "Voluntary Disclosure and Reverse False Claims," False Claims Act and Qui Tam Litigation Conference (April 2010) 
  • "Medi-Cal Enforcement: New Federal and Continued State Focus," panelist, Annual Meeting and Spring Seminar of the California Society for Healthcare Attorneys (April 2010) 
  • "Hospital Strategies for Managing Vendor Gifts and Relationships," panelist, Corporate Research Group Webinar (March 2010) 
  • "The HEAT Is on: Prepare Now for Enhanced Government Enforcement Efforts," panelist, Foley & Lardner LLP Health Care Friday Focus Web Conference Series (January 2010)

Insights

Waltz Quoted on CMS’ Final Discharge Planning Rule
30 September 2019
Report on Medicare Compliance
Waltz Comments on New CMS Program-Integrity Regulation
06 September 2019
Report on Medicare Compliance
Waltz Comments on Interview with Former HHS Inspector General
24 June 2019
Compliance Cosmos
Waltz Quoted on SCOTUS Ruling Over Medicare Payments
10 June 2019
Compliance Cosmos