The Chint V. Schneider Settlement: 157 Million Reasons to Believe Chinese Patent Holder's Rights Have Muscle
Today there was drama in the Zhejiang High People’s Court at the beginning of the oral hearing of an ongoing dispute between Chint Group Corp (Chint) and Schneider Electric Low-Voltage (Tianjin) Co., Ltd. (Schneider) (Chint v. Schneider). Schneider, the French-based leading Western manufacturer of low-voltage electronics such as switches and circuit breakers, has settled its patent lawsuit with Wenzhou-based Chint, its top Chinese competitor, for RMB 157 million (approximately U.S. $23 million). Schneider has battled with Chint on multiple continents to restrain Chint’s presence in the global marketplace. The sum is approximately half of the damages (RMB 334 million) previously awarded to Chint by the Wenzhou Intermediate People’s Court in late 2007.
Chint initiated a lawsuit on its home turf in 2006 with the Wenzhou Intermediate People’s Court against Schneider for patent infringement of one of its PRC utility model patents. During approximately two years of legal proceedings, Chint successfully defended the validity of the concerned utility model patent before the PRC Patent Reexamination Board and succeeded in the patent infringement lawsuit at the Wenzhou Intermediate People’s Court. The original RMB 334 million in damages was (and still is) the largest amount ever rewarded in China for patent infringement, and has aroused great attention in the industry, especially in view of the fact that the concerned patent was a utility model patent (which, under Chinese law, is not examined on its substance during prosecution but is registered with a substantive examination deferred until enforcement and which, accordingly, may be viewed as providing “weaker” or less certain protection of intellectual property rights than an invention patent). Schneider subsequently appealed the lower court’s ruling to the Zhejiang High People’s Court.
By Chinese standards, a RMB 157 million-settlement amount is unprecedently high and will certainly encourage more patent holders to aggressively enforce their rights in China.
법률 뉴스 알림은 고객과 동료들에게 영향을 미치는 시급한 문제나 업계 이슈에 관한 최신 정보를 제공하기 위한 당사의 지속적인 노력의 일환입니다.
본 알림에 관한 문의사항이 있거나 해당 주제에 대해 추가로 논의하고자 하시는 경우, 담당 폴리 변호사 또는 다음 담당자에게 연락주시기 바랍니다:
Sharon R. Barner
Chair, Intellectual Property Department
Chicago, Illinois
312.832.4569
[email protected]
Catherine Sun
Chair, Asia Practice
Shanghai, China
86 21 6100 8900
[email protected]
Yan Zhao
Senior Counsel, Intellectual Property Department
Shanghai, China
86 21 6100 8900
[email protected]
폴리 앤 라드너 LLP는 중국에서 외국 법률사무소로 운영할 수 있는 허가를 받았습니다. 법무부 규정에 따라 중국 내 외국 법률사무소는 국제 거래의 특정 측면에 대해 고객에게 자문을 제공하고 중국 법률 및 규제 환경의 영향에 관한 상담을 제공할 수 있으나, 중국 법률 업무를 수행할 수 없습니다. 본 커뮤니케이션의 내용은 중국 법률에 대한 의견이나 법률 자문을 구성하지 않으며, 중국 내 국제 비즈니스 거래에 관한 고객 자문을 수행한 당사의 연구 및 경험을 바탕으로 한 것입니다.