Robinson Quoted in Law360 About the Likelihood of Auto Companies Battling over Patents
February 7, 2019
Law360
Partner William Robinson, chair of the firm’s IP Litigation practice, was quoted in the Law360 article, “The Next Big Patent War? It Likely Won’t Be in Detroit,” about whether automakers are likely to have learned anything from the drawn-out legal battles of the smartphone industry over patents. According to Law360, automakers have been stockpiling patents relating to autonomous and connected cars, but IP attorneys including Robinson do not expect car companies to have the appetite to engage in litigation over patents as many smartphone-makers did in the past.
Robinson said the smartphone wars, where companies like Apple and Samsung were locked in drawn-out courtroom battles — and spent tens of millions of dollars in the process — were eye-opening for a lot of people. But was it all worth it? “The big players, if they can’t take each other out of the market — and certainly Samsung and Apple is Exhibit A for that — then what’s the point?” he said.
Robinson also pointed to broader trends in patent litigation, including the difficulties securing an injunction and the creation of America Invents Act reviews to challenge patents, that have pushed down the overall number of patent lawsuits.
“I don’t think you’ll see the smartphone wars repeated in the automotive space because the return on litigation investment dollars is just not there,” he said.
Robinson said the smartphone wars, where companies like Apple and Samsung were locked in drawn-out courtroom battles — and spent tens of millions of dollars in the process — were eye-opening for a lot of people. But was it all worth it? “The big players, if they can’t take each other out of the market — and certainly Samsung and Apple is Exhibit A for that — then what’s the point?” he said.
Robinson also pointed to broader trends in patent litigation, including the difficulties securing an injunction and the creation of America Invents Act reviews to challenge patents, that have pushed down the overall number of patent lawsuits.
“I don’t think you’ll see the smartphone wars repeated in the automotive space because the return on litigation investment dollars is just not there,” he said.
Related News
June 10, 2025
In the News
Lynn Gandhi Sheds Light on Supreme Court Tax Ruling
Foley partner Lynn Gandhi commented in the Bloomberg Tax article "High Court’s Catholic Charities Case to Go Beyond Unemployment," sharing insight on the implications of the recent Supreme Court ruling in a tax case.
June 10, 2025
In the News
James McFall Joins Iconic Athletes and Leaders in Launch of Stanford Football Alumni United
Foley & Lardner LLP is proud to announce that partner James Carlos McFall is a founding member of Stanford Football Alumni United (SFAU), a newly formed coalition of former players and leaders committed to supporting Stanford Football’s continued growth and national competitiveness.
June 6, 2025
In the News
David Rosen Comments on FDA, Compounder Conflict Over Drug Shortages
Foley & Lardner LLP partner David Rosen highlighted the U.S. Food and Drug Administration's drug shortage list in the BioSpace article, "Post-Chevron Legal Battles: Three Key Cases to Watch."