Patrick Daugherty Quoted on Regulatory Uncertainty in Prediction Markets
Foley & Lardner LLP partner Patrick Daugherty was quoted in the recent FinanceFeeds article, “Is the CFTC Poised to Step In on Event Contracts?” discussing the uncertainty surrounding whether federal derivatives regulation or state gambling laws should govern event contracts traded on prediction markets.
Daugherty points to statutory ambiguity, rather than judicial interpretation, as the root of the division, stating, “What sticks is an unambiguous federal statute that preempts facially inconsistent state law. The Dodd-Frank Act that amended the Commodity Exchange Act in 2010 is ambiguous on some key points. That’s why inconsistent results are being obtained in the courts.”
He shared that clients are taking three approaches amid the circuit split: pausing operations pending court clarity, geofencing out riskier states, or continuing nationwide while relying on the CFTC’s stance. Daugherty advised clients to apply for federal licenses now due to slow processing and backlogs.
Referencing the June 2024 Supreme Court decision in Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, he noted that some commentary overstates what changed, explaining, “Loper Bright overruled Chevron deference while leaving Skidmore deference intact. Skidmore was less deferential than Chevron, but its legacy is that well-reasoned agency decisions should still prevail.”